IRIN
PAKISTAN: Rescuing quake capital from toxic waste
29 May 2006


[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United 
Nations]

MUZAFFARABAD, 29 May (IRIN) - Seven months after the 8 October quake 
which killed at least 80,000, the stench of death has finally wafted 
away from Muzaffarabad, the capital of Pakistan-administered Kashmir. 
However, something almost as bad has come in its place. The city of 
700,000 people has been turned into a massive rubbish dump.

An estimated 25 million cu metres of rubble lies scattered across it, 
and, according to city municipal officer Zahid Kashif, just over 2 
million cu metres has been removed so far. Atop the debris, deposits of 
filth lie dumped - and in the scorching heat of May, with temperatures 
climbing above 30 degrees Celsius - it creates a terrible odour that 
never quite seems to leave some parts of the city.

A continued shortage of latrines and sanitation facilities means some 
living in the tents still dotted across the city, including 10,000 
people from Muzaffarabad itself who were left homeless by the quake, use 
open spaces as toilets. They must also survive the hostile weather in 
canvas tents, which provide almost no protection from the intensity of 
the sun. Rain, forecast by the end of June, can only add to the squalor.

"Look at how we live. Like animals, among this rubbish. And now we are 
being told it contains poison that could kill our children," Muhammad 
Rashid, 28, told IRIN. Rashid's house in Muzaffarabad collapsed during 
the quake, and he, his wife and two small children have lived in a tent 
since then.

Beyond appearances, the lingering stench and the mosquitoes that swarm 
above rubbish heaps, there is something more sinister about the heaps of 
debris. Local health officials and environmentalists fear that the 
mountain of waste and rubble contains dangerous heavy metals, including 
lead.

"The use of lead in paints is common in this part of the world. But now 
this lead, and the iron and zinc contained in the rubble, are leaching 
into the soil," said Ali Hussain, an environmental scientist working in 
Muzaffarabad.

His views have been endorsed by government officials, including Babar 
Minhas, an environmental officer who has described the situation as 
"disastrous". At a workshop in Islamabad on 27 April, Minister of State 
for the Environment in Pakistani-administered Kashmir, Mufti Mansoor, 
stated that toxic materials contained in debris were a cause for concern 
regarding health.

Across Muzaffarabad, small children, many barefoot and thinly clad, 
climb and tumble across the rubble. Experts fear these children are at 
risk of lead poisoning - which, especially in children, can cause brain 
damage and also lead to anaemia, kidney problems and harm to the nervous 
system.

"We need to test these children to determine if they have absorbed lead, 
and take steps to avert further exposure," Dr Atif Tanvir, a 
Muzaffarabad paediatrician told IRIN.

Still more worrying are the reports that rubble is being thrown directly 
into the waters of the Jehlum and Neelum rivers, which meet in 
Muzaffarabad. Their banks are now stacked with debris, and experts warn 
that the many tons thrown into them may have lead to water 
contamination.

"This could pose a threat to aquatic life, and also to the many people 
who use water for drinking or irrigation purposes," Ali Hussain 
explained.

The situation points to the perils posed by both the scale of the quake 
disaster, and the failure, some NGOs have said, to fully streamline and 
manage the aftermath. The fear now is that the effects of toxins spread 
across Muzaffarabad could leave a still longer-term and more devastating 
impact on the people who live there, with the full health consequences 
still far from clear.

The UN Resident Coordinator, Jan Vandermoortele, has already said that, 
according to estimates, at least 100,000 people will have to continue to 
live in tents until next winter. Some 10 camps, based in Pakistani- 
administered Kashmir and in the North West Frontier Province (NWFP), 
will house these people.

The offical has said that people are continuing to live in tents mainly 
because their "lands have been washed away or the area where they live 
faces a risk of further earthquakes."

Meanwhile, in Muzaffarabad, amid increasing media attention, there is an 
attempt to clear away the rubbish. But the efforts are slow, handicapped 
by a lack of equipment, and, victims claim, a lack of governmental will. 
There is, however, hopeful news from other cities. Early in May, the UN 
Development Programme (UNDP) and its implementing partner, the UN Office 
for Project Services (UNOPS), said that a rubble removal exercise had 
been completed in Bagh, Battagram and Garhi Hbaibullah districts.

"I am very pleased with the success of the project. We have succeeded in 
clearing 300,000 cu ft of rubble," said UNOPS Project Manager Geoff 
Hourn. A US $1.5 million International Organization of Migration (IOM) 
project to clear rubble in Muzzafarbad began in April.

The teams hope to complete the gigantic task over the next nine months, 
despite the problems. Project Coordinator David Savard told IRIN: "The 
task is huge and quite tough with narrow lanes making it sometimes 
impossible for the dump trucks to access the rubble sites."


IRIN-Asia
Tel: +90 312 454 1177
Fax: +90 312 495 4166
Email: IrinAsia@IRINnews.org


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Appropriate Donations for International Disaster/Humanitarian Needs
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Center for International             web: www.cidi.org
    Disaster Information         listserv: www.cidi.org/listsub.htm
                               guidelines: www.cidi.org/donate.htm
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
South Asia Earthquake               www.cidi.org/incident/sasia-05j