Weekly Round-Up - IRINSA-46: 23-Nov-01

U N I T E D   N A T I O N S
Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
Integrated Regional Information Network for Southern Africa

Tel: +27 11 880 4633
Fax: +27 11 880 1421
e-mail: irin-sa@irin.org.za

SOUTHERN AFRICA IRIN-SA Weekly Round-up 46 17 - 23 November 2001

CONTENTS: ZIMBABWE: European Union snubbed by Mugabe ZAMBIA: Election date finally announced ANGOLA: Partial Angolan troop withdrawal from DRC MALAWI: Muluzi urged to 'defend constitution' SOUTH AFRICA: SA urged to nab traffickers MOZAMBIQUE: Fears of more flooding NAMIBIA: Condemnation of new policy on UNITA "collaborators" LESOTHO: NGOs lobby against electoral bill ZIMBABWE: European Union snubbed by Mugabe Zimbabwe found itself further isolated internationally this week when a European Union (EU) delegation said it had failed to hold constructive talks with President Robert Mugabe on Friday 23 November, and that its relations with the country had reached a "critical point". "Our relations are now at a critical point, we have to admit that, we have arrived at a critical point," said Belgian Foreign Minister Louis Michel, who headed the EU team. The EU is considering imposing sanctions against Zimbabwe because of mounting human rights abuses and the government's crackdown on civil liberties. The 15-member bloc is also concerned about President Robert Mugabe's refusal to guarantee fair elections next year and the admission of international observers. Zimbabwe's controversial land reform programme is also expected to come under the spotlight. Early this month, EU foreign ministers agreed to invoke Article 96 of the Cotonou agreement that governs relations between the European Union and its African, Caribbean and Pacific partners. The move meant that the EU was to formally ask Zimbabwe to discuss such issues as land reform, ending political violence, ensuring press freedom and judicial independence, and allowing election observers at next year's presidential poll. Michel added it was difficult to engage in constructive dialogue with Mugabe during Friday's 90-minute talks. "We didn't have the opportunity to have a constructive exchange of views," said the Belgian foreign minister. "But today it was not really easy to have this discussion, we just put on the table the issues and there was a brutal reaction," Michel told a news conference shortly before leaving Harare for Bujumbura. For a background story on the EU visit: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15832&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa&SelectCountry=ZIMBABWE Civil rights march thwarted Mugabe, however, weathered a demonstration planned for Wednesday. The protest march by civic groups in Harare over amendments to the country's electoral act was thwarted by an army of riot police who prevented protesters from approaching parliament. The marchers were confronted outside parliament by riot police wielding batons. The police chased the marchers back towards the city centre where the demonstration fizzled out. At least 25 demonstrators were arrested for public order offences. The protest was over what they say are changes to the country's electoral laws ahead of next year's presidential elections which would disenfranchise millions of expatriate Zimbabweans and bar NGOs from voter education and election monitoring. The march was planned by the National Constitutional Assembly (NCA) - an umbrella NGO bringing together student groups, human rights organisations, churches, trade unions and political parties. The NCA has campaigned for a new constitution for Zimbabwe as well as free and fair elections and an independent electoral authority. For the full IRIN story: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15605&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa&SelectCountry=ZIMBABWE Citizens forced to carry identity papers In a move seen as another clampdown on dissenters, the government is to introduce laws to force Zimbabweans to carry identity cards at all times, the state-controlled Herald reported on Thursday. Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa was quoted as saying that "the country must be protected from terrorism" and this could only be possible if police were empowered by law to demand identity cards from people who move within the country. The right of police to demand identity cards was abolished by the supreme court in 1997, when it ruled that it was a violation of constitutional guarantees of freedom of movement. The opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) immediately said it would block the move. "It's plainly unconstitutional," said MDC Secretary-General Welshman Ncube. Meanwhile, the Zimbabwean Supreme Court threw out charges of terrorism against MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai on Tuesday, saying the charges contravened sections of the constitution. "Our application was successful. The Supreme Court unanimously found the sections under which he was charged to be in contravention of section 18 of the constitution," said Tsvangirai's lawyer, Innocent Chagonda. Tsvangirai was charged with terrorism and sabotage after telling a rally last year that President Robert Mugabe should stand down or face violent removal. The ruling clears the way for Tsvangirai to challenge Mugabe in presidential elections next year. If he had been found guilty he would have faced a possible jail sentence. NGOs fear being targeted as violence escalates But Zimbabwe's Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) fear being next on a "hit-list" after a weekend of political violence, representatives of civil society said on Monday. "It's open season now on the opposition and white farmers, government label us as anti-state so we're expecting the worst," the head of a prominent Harare-based NGO told IRIN anonymously, fearing reprisals. In the last month, NGOs and civil groups have come under increasing government scrutiny. Last week Information Minister Jonathan Moyo said local and international NGOs would not be allowed to distribute emergency food aid that Zimbabwe has requested from foreign donors. Such groups have also effectively been banned from monitoring and observing the election. In a recent interview with the BBC, Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa said local monitors would be government appointees and international observers could only play a role in the election process "when invited". For the full IRIN story: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15172&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa&SelectCountry=ZIMBABWE Government to limit farm sizes Zimbabwe said on Monday it would limit farms not earmarked for seizure to a maximum of 2,000 hectares each and give left-over space to the landless. "Government has decided that every property that has not been gazetted for compulsory acquisition should immediately be sub-divided to comply with the maximum size regulations," Agriculture Minister Joseph Made told a news conference. The limits would range between 250 and 2,000 hectares, depending on the type of land, Made said. Properties affected by the rules would include large-scale commercial farms not targeted for government seizure and properties belonging to foreign nationals, he added. "We believe that small farms and related enterprises will be more productive than the current large farms," he said. Analysts dubbed the move economic suicide, while the Commercial Farmers Union (CFU) representing white farmers, said it spelt the end of commercial agriculture in Zimbabwe. However, the government plans to allocate about a dozen large-scale farms or the equivalent of 10,000 hectares of land to Libyan entrepreneurs as part of an economic cooperation package between Zimbabwe and its north African ally, the Financial Gazette reported on Thursday. Poverty breeds opposition A visitor to Joseph Shonga's home can't help but notice the large fissure that zigzags from the roof of his mud hut, down the decaying wall, and into the ground. A few metres from the crumbling dwelling is a stinking metal and plastic shack that serves as the toilet for Shonga's family. These images of poverty and squalor are everywhere at Porta farm, a fast-expanding squatter camp 18 km southwest of Zimbabwe's capital, Harare. For the full IRIN story: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15104&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa&SelectCountry=ZIMBABWE ZAMBIA: Election date finally announced Ending months of uncertainty, Zambian President Fredrick Chiluba announced on Thursday 22 November that presidential, parliamentary and local government elections would be held on 27 December, news agencies reported. Parliament is to be dissolved on 8 December, a brief statement issued by the presidency said. Announcing the election date ends months of speculation and criticism of Chiluba's silence. As Zambia's rainy season runs from November to March, many civic leaders and opposition officials worry some voters might be cut off from their polling stations and effectively disenfranchised. This week, human rights groups were divided over whether to support a call by opposition parties for a public disobedience campaign to press Chiluba to make the date public. Chiluba is to step down as president after a decade in power, and the ruling Movement for Multiparty Democracy (MMD) has chosen Levy Mwanawasa as its candidate to replace him. Nine opposition leaders will contest the presidency. Mwanawasa's biggest challenge is expected to come from Christon Tembo, a former army commander who leads the fledgling opposition Forum for Democracy and Development (FDD). The FDD is likely to pose the strongest challenge to the ruling party. Anti-torture law promised The Zambian government has agreed to "domesticate" the standards of the international Convention against Torture into domestic law, according to a press release by the UN office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. The UN's Committee against Torture concluded its consideration on Tuesday of a report by the Zambian government which committed the country to translate the standards of the convention into international law "as a matter of priority", and that a specific definition of the crime of torture would be established. Committee members on Monday had noted a "lack of consonance" between the Zambian legal regime and the convention. They decried, for example, the admissibility in court of evidence extracted under torture, leading to "widespread" maltreatment of suspects by police officers. ANGOLA: Partial Angolan troop withdrawal from DRC Belgian Foreign Minister Louis Michel said after a meeting with Angolan President Jose Eduardo dos Santos on Thursday that Angola would withdraw a significant number of its troops from the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). However, Michel declined to reveal the proportion of Angolan forces to be withdrawn. Angola is estimated to have 2,000-2,500 troops in the country. A European Union delegation, headed by Michel, seeking a solution for the regional war in the DRC, arrived in Luanda for talks with Angolan leaders. The EU team, including EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana, met separately with Dos Santos and Foreign Minister Joao Miranda as part of a five-day mission to promote peace in the DRC and Burundi. Zambia admits killing 10 Angolan soldiers Zambian President Frederick Chiluba on Thursday said that the country's armed forces had shot dead 10 Angolan soldiers on Wednesday in a border incident near where seven Zambian villagers were killed two weeks ago. "I regret that our soldiers killed 10 Angolan soldiers last night," Chiluba was quoted as telling a business delegation in the country's northern mining city of Kitwe. The president said Zambia's northwestern border with Angola remained tense but gave no further details. Meanwhile, Angola has refused to take responsibility for the deaths of the Zambian villagers allegedly killed when Angolan forces crossed into Zambia in pursuit of suspected UNITA rebels. Speaking in Lusaka after delivering a message from Dos Santos to Chiluba, Angolan presidential envoy George Chikoti was quoted as saying that it was difficult to ascertain whether the Zambians were actually killed by Angolan security forces. Chikoti suggested that the seven Zambians might have been caught in a crossfire between the Angolan Armed Forces and the UNITA rebels. Military call-up In a separate development, in the last few weeks, radio announcements have been instructing young men aged between 18 and 20 to report to military bases around the country to register for military service, as is normal at this time of year. But the FAA also have the legal right to conscript men up to the age of 30 who have not previously served for two years. Many young men fear that even those who have served their time could still be forced to put on uniforms. The army has recently stepped up its operations in the eastern province of Moxico, saying that the aim is to capture Jonas Savimbi and to destroy the last UNITA forces in a region where the rebels are well established. Young men who hear this worry that it will be a signal for the military to make a particular effort this year - after 26 years of war - to get more of them into the army. Whether or not this is actually happening remains unclear. The conscription laws in Angola are never applied consistently. For the full IRIN story: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15933 MALAWI: Muluzi urged to 'defend constitution' The Magistrates' and Judges' Association of Malawi this week wrote to President Bakili Muluzi, urging him to reject his United Democratic Front (UDF) MPs attempts to sack three senior High Court judges. Parliament passed three UDF MP's motions on Wednesday 14 November, recommending the judges' dismissal to Muluzi. The judges - Justice Dunstain Mwaungulu, Justice Chimasula Phiri and Justice Anaclet Chipeta - were accused by the MPs of supporting opposition leaders, ruling in their favour in a number of cases and prejudicing the UDF. The petition has sparked a major row between parliament and the judiciary which could, according to several lawyers, lead to a constitutional crisis - a crisis which Muluzi could now flame with the stroke of a pen. Dingiswayo Madise, president of the Magistrate's and Judge's Association, told IRIN on Monday that because Muluzi had not yet endorsed parliament's petition, the association decided to petition him themselves. "I delivered the petition to the presidential palace myself," he said. "We addressed our concerns to the president, urging him not to sign (parliament's) petitions and to keep his word and the oath he took to defend the constitution. We are urging him as a democrat to not sign those petitions." For the full IRIN story: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15192&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa&SelectCountry=MALAWI IRIN interview with democracy activist, Rafiq Hajat Rafiq Hajat describes himself as a "political activist and grassroots person". He is an executive member of Malawi's ruling United Democratic Front (UDF), vice president of the country's chamber of commerce and industry, chairman of DEMAT, the Development of Malawian Traders' Trust, and also founding director of the Institute for Policy Interaction (IPI). For the full IRIN interview: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15199&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa&SelectCountry=MALAWI Suspended aid to resume soon - government In a separate development, a government spokesman told IRIN on Tuesday that millions of dollars worth of aid to Malawi suspended due to corruption and the curtailment of the government's privatisation programme will be released soon. "Although some aid had been suspended because of problems over privatisation, agreement has been reached with donors and the monies are set to flow again," Anthony Livuza said. According to a report on Monday in Malawi's Daily Times, the European Union (EU), the United States and British governments have suspended K1.5 billion (US $23 million) worth of aid pledged for this year's budget because of top level corruption and the suspension of the government's controversial privatisation programme. According to the Daily Times, the EU had decided to withhold K700 million (US $10 million) and had asked government to refund K400 million (US $5.2 million) alleged to have been misused by government in the tendering of the rehabilitation of the Blantyre-Chileka road. For the full IRIN story: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15392&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa&SelectCountry=MALAWI SOUTH AFRICA: SA urged to nab traffickers A United Nations panel on Monday urged South Africa to tighten its laws against traffickers who were using the country as transit point to smuggle illicit high-value commodities. The panel recommended in its report on the plunder of natural resources in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) that a moratorium be placed on the importation of gold, diamonds, copper, cobalt, timber, coffee and other valuable commodities from rebel-held areas of the country. In its response, the South African government said in a statement on Thursday: "It is stated in the Addendum that the Panel has credible information indicating that various actors, some based in South Africa and others outside, are using the territories and facilities of South Africa to conduct illicit commercial activities involving the natural resources of the DRC. It is surprising that the Expert Panel neither mentioned this during its meetings in South Africa, nor did it at any stage share with the Government the evidence that it claims to have in this regard. The government will now seek to obtain the information from the Expert Panel in order to take appropriate action where necessary." MOZAMBIQUE: Fears of more flooding Fears of flooding in southern Mozambique mounted this week after the regions water authorities forecasted heavy rains in the next two weeks. Authorities said that because of continued heavy rain, the Pequenos Limbombos dam south of Maputo, might have to increase its discharge rate to hold more water during the rainy season. Meanwhile, a spokesman for the UN's World Food Programme in Maputo told IRIN on Friday 23 November that 235,000 people throughout Mozambique would need some form of food aid, starting in December. "The hungry season in Mozambique normally begins in about December and runs through until February. This year it started early. Added to this farmers have not had a very good season. The hungry season is a time when traditionally people do not have enough food in their storage bins and turn to secondary sources for food." He explained to IRIN that most of the aid would be in the form of food-for-work programmes. "Of this 235,000 there are still those that are recovery from the floods and are still in camps waiting to be resettled. This will receive direct food aid or be part of food-for-recovery programmes," he said. Club of Paris slashes Mozambique's debt Meanwhile, the Club of Paris announced on Tuesday that it was reducing Mozambique's debt by US $1.65 billion, more than half the amount owed by the African country to the group of creditor nations. According to the Portuguese LUSA news agency, the group said in a statement issued in Paris that the debt reduction came in recognition of Maputo's "important efforts in the framework of economic and structural reforms" overseen by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. NAMIBIA: Condemnation of new policy on UNITA "collaborators" Namibia's National Society for Human Rights (NSHR) this week condemned a warning by Defence Minister Erkki Nghimtina that anybody found "collaborating" with Angolan UNITA rebels would be shot on sight. In a statement released on Wednesday, NSHR condemned as unconstitutional "the pronounced policy of shoot-on-sight anyone perceived to be collaborating with the alleged enemies". Nghimtina reportedly made the remarks at the weekend in the insecure northern Kavango region, which borders Angola. According to Namibian national radio, Nghimtina issued the warning that "enemies" would be shot when addressing a consultative meeting of government officials, representatives of the private sector, and regional and traditional leaders, the NSHR statement said. According to the NSHR, the minister's comments have provided credence to the human rights group's allegations that Namibian forces in southeast Angola had carried out "massacres, enforced disappearances and summary executions" of civilians suspected of siding with UNITA. Namibian troops operate inside Angola in a bid to prevent the rebels from crossing into Kavango. For the full story: http://www.irinnews.org/report.asp?ReportID=15606&SelectRegion=Southern_Africa&SelectCountry=NAMIBIA Red cross withdraws from Osire The Namibian Red Cross Society (NRCS) told IRIN this week that it was withdrawing its services from the Osire refugee camp. "We will be withdrawing as of 31 December 2001," Geniene Veii, deputy secretary-general of the NRCS told IRIN on Tuesday. "Part of the reason that we are doing this is because of a lack of donor funding and partly because donors have been slow in making payments." "It needs to be emphasised that we are not abandoning the refugees and we will continue with some services such as tracing which includes re-establishing links between families." she said. The NRCS has, up to now, acted as UNHCR's main implementing partner at the camp, helping with issues such as sanitation, food distribution and water provision. UNHCR in Namibia told IRIN that it was informed of the NRCS decision in September. "We have had some time to prepare and we have already approached some organisations who might be willing to work with us at Osire," a UNHCR spokesman said. Meanwhile, The Namibian newspaper reported on Friday 23 November that Africa Humanitarian Africa (AHA) would act as UNHCR's new implementing partner. The report said that the organisation had already deployed a medical officer to Osire and taken on the 14 clinic staff. LESOTHO: NGOs lobby against electoral bill Lesotho's NGOs are lobbying against a complex election bill which they allege could deepen the country's political instability if passed by parliament. The Elections Amendment Bill being debated introduces a "mixed member" system under which 80 MPs are to be elected under a first-past-the-post constituency-based system, with another 40 members to be elected on the basis of proportional representation. According to the bill, the allocation of seats for one party will be determined by dividing the total votes by 120 or any number of constituencies that successfully contested elections, including the 40 proportional representation seats, the Maseru newspaper Mopheme reported Seabat Motsamai, the acting director of the Lesotho NGO Council, told IRIN that the two ballot papers needed for the mixed member system was confusing. "The level of voter education is not enough for people to grasp the need for two ticks." He added that the complicated new electoral system proposed by both the Interim Political Authority and the Independent Electoral Commission was not the proportional representation the country's NGOs supported. "Literally what they (the authorities) are saying is to take the country as one constituency and see what support you have," rather than reserving 40 seats for proportional representation alone, based on the number of votes won by each party. IRIN-SA Tel: +27 11 880-4633 Fax: +27 11 447-5472 Email: IRIN-SA@irin.org.za [This Item is Delivered to the "Africa-English" Service of the UN's IRIN humanitarian information unit, but may not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations. For further information, free subscriptions, or to change your keywords, contact e-mail: IRIN@ocha.unon.org or Web: http://www.irinnews.org . If you re-print, copy, archive or re-post this item, please retain this credit and disclaimer. Reposting by commercial sites requires written IRIN permission.] Copyright (c) UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs 2001 distributed by - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Center for International Disaster Information Volunteers in Technical Assistance web: www.cidi.org listserv: www.cidi.org/listsub.htm - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Southern Africa www.cidi.org/humanitarian/irin/safrica